Cité des Sciences et de l'Industrie
Accueil

   

Index

Biodiversity: the end for wildlife?

Tous les dossiers

Palaeontology/Archaeology

last questions on current events

DEBATE:
a secret chamber in the Great Pyramid?

According to two amateur Egyptologists, the Great Pyramid could hold a fourth, hidden chamber that may be the tomb of the pharaoh Cheops. The hypothesis still has to be checked on site, but the Egyptian authorities refuse to allow any verification for the time being.

At the Egyptology congress...

From the 6th to the 12th September, Grenoble hosted the 9th International Congress of Egyptologists, which provided an opportunity for hundreds of researchers from all over the world to exchange ideas and present their latest work. Surprisingly, it was a conference organised by “non-professionals" that caused the greatest stir.

Gilles Dormion and Jean-Yves Verd'hurt
zoom
Gilles Dormion and Jean-Yves Verd'hurt

On the third day of the event, architect Gilles Dormion and his companion in the field Jean-Yves Verd'hurt presented the results of several years' work on the Great Pyramid of Giza.


One of their conclusions was that there may be an unopened chamber in the edifice, perhaps holding the remains of the pharaoh Cheops! They have devoted a 300-page book – La chambre de Chéops (The Chamber of Cheops) – to their theory, a subject of fierce debate in the world of Egyptology.

« La chambre de Chéops », Gilles Dormion, publishing Fayard, 2004
zoom
« La chambre de Chéops », Gilles Dormion, publishing Fayard, 2004

An architectural investigation

Gilles Dormion and Jean-Yves Verd'hurt have been studying the pyramids for nearly seventeen years, but unlike professional Egyptologists, the two men are essentially interested in the structural aspect of the monuments.

Their method, a sort of “architectural investigation", consists of studying the structure of an edifice down to the tiniest details, taking care to note every anomaly. Any unusual alignment of joints or flagstones, fissures or gaps are all clues to the internal structure of an edifice.

The method has already proved successful. In 2000, Gilles Dormion and his companion uncovered two “relieving chambers" in the Meidum pyramid.

The Great Pyramid of Cheops
zoom
The Great Pyramid of Cheops

Three empty chambers

The Pyramid of Cheops, the last of the Seven Wonders of the World, is one of a kind. First, because of its size (at 137 metres, it is the tallest pyramid ever built), but also because it is the only one to have three distinct chambers.

Located under the pyramid, the first room could have been a royal burial chamber, but for reasons still unknown, it was never finished.

Plan of the Great Pyramid : 1. Coating (gone); 2. Entrance; 3. Descending corridor; 4. Underground chamber; 5. Ascending corridor; 6. Service corridor; 7. Horizontal corridor; 8. Queen’s chamber; 9. Ventilation shafts; 10. Great gallery; 11. Antechamber; 12. King’s chamber; 13. Relieving chambers.
zoom
Plan of the Great Pyramid

The second, called the Queen’s Chamber (although Cheops’ wife was not buried there), is located in the heart of the edifice. It is a relatively small room – too small for a pharaoh according to Gilles Dormion – and no-one knows what its true purpose was.

It follows that the mummy of Cheops should have been entombed in the last chamber, on a higher level. However, this “King’s chamber” is empty. Was it looted? Gilles Dormion does not think so. In his opinion, several clues show that when the pyramid was being built, the ceiling of the chamber was in danger of falling in, so the builders decided not to risk placing the remains of their sovereign there. But if that is so, where is Cheops?

A strange niche : The hole visible in its centre was made by looters.
zoom
A strange niche

A strange niche

Gilles Dormion and Jean-Yves Verd’hurt actually found their most vital clues in the Queen’s chamber.

The presence of a niche in the east wall of the room is puzzling. Some Egyptologists say that it was intended to hold a statue. That is actually the simplest explanation[…],notes Gilles Dormion. However, we must remember that it is not based on any tangible evidence, but is only suggested by default. »


Approaching the niche, it becomes apparent that looters opened a passage about fifteen metres deep there, probably in vain, since it does not lead anywhere. However, when Gilles Dormion entered the passage and examined the masonry, he decided that it must originally have been a “service passage” built into the pyramid, five cubits long (2.62 m) and coming to a dead end.

Studying the floor closely, Gilles Dormion found a rectangular hole (10 x 12 cm) directed downwards and blocked by a limestone plug, the sort of hole that portcullis ropes pass through. And where there is a portcullis, there is a passage… and a passage must lead somewhere! Indeed, we know that portcullis systems were used to block the burial chambers of pharaohs, such as the “King’s chamber“.

Ground probing radar used in the Queen’s chamber : Ground probing radar shows that there is a structure (probably a ceiling) 3.5 m under the Queen’s chamber.
zoom
Ground probing radar used in the Queen’s chamber

A “structure” under the Queen’s chamber?

Now, Gilles Dormion found a second clue: the paving of the Queen’s chamber seems to have been “modified”. Studying it in detail, the architect reached the conclusion that the flagstones were taken up to gain access to the lower level, so there must be something under the Queen’s chamber...

In September 2000, Gilles Dormion was given permission to use ground probing radar to probe the floor of the room and check his hypothesis. He immediately obtained a positive result: 3.5 m under the Queen’s chamber, there is probably an unknown structure 2 cubits (about 1 metre) in width. Could the chamber of Cheops be located at the end of it??

« At this stage, we can say that there is a very strong probability that there is a passage under the Queen’s chamber,Gilles Dormion explains. But until we’ve checked visually, we can’t be 100% sure.”

According to Gilles Dormion, the hypothetical chamber would be located under the Queen’s chamber and to the west.
zoom
According to Gilles Dormion, the hypothetical chamber would be located under the Queen’s chamber and to the west.

An initial operation, such as passing an endoscope through a hole 15 mm in diameter drilled into the floor of the Queen’s chamber, would show whether there is granite 3.5 metres down (granite was used to build ceilings; the rest of the pyramid is made of limestone). However, Zahi Hawass, general secretary of the Supreme Council of Egyptian Antiquities, the sole authority that can authorise a dig, does not look kindly on the idea…

Zahi Hawass, general secretary of the Supreme Council of Egyptian Antiquities... : Interview made during the Egyptology Congress at Grenoble.
Zahi Hawass, general secretary of the Supreme Council of Egyptian Antiquities...

“Amateurs!”

« They’re amateurs, not scientists, seethes Zahi Hawass, who was present at the Grenoble Egyptology congress. I have more than three hundred files like theirs on my desk. I can’t allow drilling like that in the Great Pyramid on the basis of just theories! »

Gilles Dormion and Jean-Yves Verd’hurt make no secret of the fact that they are not Egyptologists. But does that mean they should be considered amateurs? The architect has drawn up the best plans of the Great Pyramid and is behind the ventilation system currently used in the monument. Also, his method of study revealed the existence of two chambers in the Meidum pyramid in 2000.

Where do you see your research going from here?  Gilles Dormion...
Where do you see your research going from here?

Gilles Dormion...

In fact, the two men have the support of several eminent Egyptologists, including Nicolas Grimal, professor at the Collège de France and honorary director of the French Institute of Eastern Archaeology, who wrote the preface for La chambre de Chéops.

It was also on his initiative and in his institution’s name that the official excavation request was made to the Egyptian Antiquities authority. When Zahi Hawass rejected the application, Michel Vallogia, an Egyptologist at the University of Geneva, repeated it, but his request also met with a refusal.

« Although Nicolas Grimal and Michel Vallogia are scientists, they’re not experts on the Great Pyramid,Zahi Hawass argues. There are only three experts on the Pyramid of Cheops: the German Stadelman, the American Lehner and myself. »


What do you hope to achieve with the publication of “La chambre de Chéops”? Gilles Dormion’s answer...

By publishing his book and attending the Congress of Egyptologists, Gilles Dormion undoubtedly hoped to make his theory a little better known and so get things moving. But given the latest statements from the general secretary of Egyptian Antiquities, the situation seems to have reached complete deadlock.

OIivier Boulanger


On line since 30/09/04
Updated 04/10/04

SEE ALSO

Livres

La chambre de Chéops - Analyse architecturale, Gilles Dormion, Ed. Fayard, 311 p., 25 €

   © CSI Science Actualités contact